A fifth.
Because when he asked his wife how many eggs to buy, she said 4!
Devil: You told people you'd say hi to other people 3,789 times but only did it 4 times. Me: OK that's fair.
They don't find them Hume-erous.
Jail-birds!
They exorcise.
A roamin' Catholic.*
Breaking the fifth wall.
Bottom of the fifth, of course.