The pirate responds, "arrr! I've no idea, but it's drivin' me nuts!"
Ayy ayy cap'n
AR-Kansas
She cried. I responded, "Well, I can't. That's why I'm doing it to her."
Because when their opponent makes a point, they always respond with a valid counterpoint.
Only 2, but I have no idea how you're gonna fit both of them inside a lightbulb.
He finishes her drink EDIT: Apparently this is Conan's joke, so all credit goes to him. I just heard it from a friend of mine and I had no idea.
Oh caaamel ye faithful.
About Ye big.
The pirate responds: "Arr, its been drivin' me nuts."