Everyone knows that the person who gave you the gift is Santa.
Nunavut.
You'd think it'd be the punchline, but apparently it's funnier when the person feints...
Three. One to get the punchline, and one to point out the math is wrong.
He pointed outside and said "The ATM machine" c/o /u/jubileo5
He sold his soul to Santa.
They both steal cookies)
Shrugs.
He's still there.
A blue slipper
The man on the moon? Santa Claus? Or an honest Lawyer? Yes you got it Santa. The other two are figments of the imagination.
I don't know. He still hasn't opened his gifts.
God's punishing you for waiting until the flight home to buy your wife a gift.